What to Know About Applying for a Full Professor (Catedrático) Position in Spain

One of the best-kept secrets in Spanish universities is that promotions to Full Professor (Catedrático/a de Universidad) are competitive. Spanish law explicitly requires these positions to be awarded through a merit-based competition.

But in practice, many of these competitions are organized for one person.

Universities go through the motions: publish a call, assemble a selection committee, invite the candidate to present their work, evaluate their merits, and eventually award the position. Everything looks like a legitimate hiring process. But in many cases, the outcome is widely anticipated before the competition even begins.

These are what we should call phony hiring processes. And they are not unique to Full Professor positions. We see similar practices at other academic ranks.

So can external candidates apply?

The short answer is yes. There are two essential requirements. First, you must have the appropriate Spanish accreditation to become a Catedrático/a de Universidad. Second, you must have completed at least two years of effective service in the academic position from which you are seeking promotion.

The Spanish LOSU states:

“Sólo podrán acceder a dichas plazas profesoras y profesores que hayan prestado, como mínimo, dos años de servicios efectivos en el puesto de origen y que estén acreditados para la categoría a la que promocionan.”

In English:

“Only professors who have completed at least two years of effective service in their position of origin and who are accredited for the category to which they seek promotion may access these positions.”

Notice something important. The law says puesto de origen. It does not say that those two years must have been completed at the university advertising the position.

Several Spanish universities interpret this provision as allowing accredited Profesores Titulares from other universities to compete. Others take a much more restrictive approach. The Universitat de Girona, for example, has published internal-promotion calls requiring candidates to already be employed at the UdG and to have completed two years of service there.

I question whether universities should be allowed to add such restrictions. The LOSU establishes the requirements for accessing these positions and then says something else that deserves attention:

“En todo caso, el procedimiento de acceso será el de concurso de méritos.”

In other words, the selection process must be a merit-based competition.

Why require a competition if universities can restrict participation to the person they already intend to promote?

Is it unethical to apply for a position designed for someone else?

Some academics might hesitate to apply for a position that was clearly created for another professor. Perhaps they feel that they would be interfering with someone’s long-awaited promotion.

But I think we should turn that ethical question around.

What are the ethics of organizing a supposedly competitive hiring process when the institution has already decided who should win?

If a university advertises a public competition, qualified academics should not feel guilty about competing.

The internal candidate is not losing their existing job if someone else wins. A tenured Profesor Titular remains a tenured Profesor Titular. What is being contested is the new position at the higher academic rank.

And if an external candidate has a stronger academic record, why shouldn’t that person have a chance?

There are many excellent academics in Spain who deserve promotion to Catedrático. But we should also acknowledge that some Full Professors have relatively weak publication records, limited international exposure, and little success obtaining competitive research funding.

Is it right to promote someone to the highest academic rank simply because they have been around for a long time?

A Full Professorship should recognize academic excellence, not simply seniority or institutional loyalty. Research, teaching, supervision, academic leadership and other relevant merits should be evaluated according to transparent criteria. And when two qualified candidates compete, the strongest candidate under those criteria should win.

How are Full Professor positions distributed?

It may surprise some readers to learn how these positions are often allocated.

Universities have a limited number of positions available for promotion, subject to their budgets, employment planning and applicable public-sector rules. These opportunities are then distributed across faculties and departments, often following internal prioritization procedures.

Within departments, seniority and the length of time someone has been waiting for promotion is usually the main consideration.

In some cases, the process begins to resemble a line at the market. Someone has been waiting for years, so now it is their turn.

This may be an understandable way to manage internal expectations. But it is not the same as identifying the strongest available academic for a Full Professor position.

If a university genuinely wants to promote an existing employee, it should have an honest and transparent mechanism for doing so. If it advertises a competitive position, it should be prepared for competition.

Trying to have it both ways creates the problem.

Why do universities continue using this system?

One argument I often hear is that universities have no choice.

“We don’t like this system either, but it is what the Spanish government requires.”

I find this explanation unconvincing.

Spanish university legislation has been reformed repeatedly. If there were broad agreement that these artificial competitions were undesirable, why have we not created a more transparent distinction between internal promotion and open recruitment?

Why do we continue to organize elaborate competitions for positions that everyone understands were intended for one person?

I suspect there are at least two reasons.

The first is financial.

A more systematic promotion model, with regular career reviews and clearly established advancement criteria, could create greater financial obligations for universities and the government. The current system allows institutions to limit the number of Full Professor positions available each year.

Rather than promoting everyone who meets a defined standard, universities can ration promotion opportunities according to available positions and budgets.

That helps control costs.

The second reason is more troubling.

The current system helps normalize and legitimize hiring processes that are not genuinely competitive.

When universities repeatedly organize competitions with an expected winner, the practice becomes routine. Everyone knows how it works. Everyone understands that the advertised position is probably intended for a particular person.

There is a public announcement. There is a committee. There are evaluation criteria. There is a presentation. There is a final resolution.

And the university can point to all these steps as evidence that the position was awarded through a legitimate merit-based process.

This creates a veneer of legitimacy around decisions that may have been largely predetermined.

It also creates a culture in which questioning the process becomes difficult. Academics who have themselves benefited from similar competitions may be reluctant to criticize them. Others know that they may eventually need their own department to organize a promotion and may not want to challenge the system on which their future advancement depends.

The incentives favour silence.

Over time, these practices can become self-reinforcing. The distinction between a genuine competition and a ceremonial one becomes increasingly blurred.

I think this is one of the most damaging aspects of academic hiring in Spain. It is not simply that some positions may be designed for insiders. It is that the system repeatedly presents these decisions to the public as the outcomes of open, merit-based competitions.

And when nearly everyone participates in the same system, there is little incentive to question it.

How can we change this?

I think one of the most effective things academics can do is surprisingly simple.

Start applying for Full Professor positions at other universities.

Every year, Spanish universities advertise many positions for Catedrático/a de Universidad. A substantial number are internal-promotion calls, often associated with a particular professor. I suspect that many of these competitions receive only one application. Instilling genuine competition in postitions is our best strategy to change the system. It could even force a reform to the current reliance on phoney hiring processes. If you do not like the phoney hiring processes, then the best thing you can do is apply for other positions, and work to force a change.

The role of Faculty Radar

Faculty Radar was created to make academic hiring in Spain more transparent. By bringing positions from universities across Spain into one searchable platform, we can make opportunities visible to academics who might never otherwise have encountered them. And that includes Full Professor positions.

If you are an accredited Profesor Titular with at least two years of service, I encourage you to look at the Catedrático positions advertised on Faculty Radar.

Read the eligibility requirements carefully. Check whether the university allows candidates from other institutions. Examine the teaching and research profile. And if you meet the requirements, consider applying.

If the university excludes you solely because you work elsewhere, I would be interested in hearing about it. These cases could help us understand how universities are interpreting the LOSU and whether some restrictions deserve legal scrutiny.

Ultimately, I would like to see a Spanish university system in which internal promotions are honest internal promotions, and open competitions are genuine open competitions.

There is nothing wrong with promoting excellent faculty who have spent their careers at one institution. But there is something deeply wrong with presenting a predetermined promotion as an open competition simply to give it the appearance of legitimacy.

We should want the strongest academics to become Full Professors, regardless of which university currently employs them.

Perhaps the next Full Professor position advertised in your field was created with someone else in mind.

But that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t take a look.

And perhaps, by applying, you can help make the Spanish academic hiring system a little more honest.

Leave a Comment